Back to main page

Insects are a diverse class of animals that are part of the food web on which many vertebrate species depend. Butterflies, bees, wasps and even mosquitoes pollinate plants that then provide fruits and seeds for other animals. Flies and beetles eat rotting debris, which helps recycle nutrients in the ecosystem. Aphids and many other soft-bodied insects suck the juices of plants and are themselves a high-protein food for other insects, reptiles, amphibians, birds and mammals.

Most insects are so small and so intimately connected to vegetation that it is difficult to avoid spraying them directly, along with the invasive plants being treated. Honeybees are routinely tested for sensitivity to herbicides and are broadly representative of other insects. While most herbicide active ingredients used in wildland weed management pose low acute risks to invertebrate species, some of the inert ingredients in formulated herbicide products may pose a greater risk. For example, some oil-based emulsifiable concentrate formulations may be harmful to soft-bodied adult or larval insects like aphids or caterpillars. The plot below shows the relative risk of a representative set of herbicides used in wildland weed management.

HoneyBeeRisk2

Reading the chart: For each bar, the labeled central value is the most likely estimate. The right end of the bar assumes worst-case conditions for all underlying variables; the left end of the bar assumes best-case conditions. Mitigation is advised if risk enters the red zone.

Taxa: Honey bees are used as a surrogate for all terrestrial insects.

Assumptions: Terrestrial application of herbicide at half of the maximum rate on a representative product label (see Table 4-1); 50% of the bee’s body surface is covered with herbicide; 100% of herbicide is absorbed; the distance between the bee and the sprayer is 0-10 feet.

Likelihood: Most likely with spray-to-wet applications on blooming plants or those with extrafloral nectaries.

Mitigation: Do not apply to blooming plants. Apply early in the morning or close to sunset when insects are less active. Use low-volume applications and reduce the amount applied per acre.

Risk calculated as a function of: The inherent toxicity of the herbicide to honey bees; the amount of active ingredient sprayed; and the distance between bee and applicator. Risks in this chart do not account for potential toxicity of any surfactants that are part of the product formulation or added to spray mixtures.

Methodology and sources

Back to main page

UA-21813186-1